Skip Navigation
  • Free Shipping.
  • Free Exchanges.
  • 365-Day Returns.
Enjoy 20% off your order of $80 or more with code: SUNSHINE15restrictions
KEEN Toyah MJ Black
Click above to zoom
Click above to zoom

Women's KEEN Toyah MJ

$74.97 $99.95 You save 25% Low Price Guarantee!
As low as $13.50 / month with PayMyWay

Sorry, we no longer carry this item

Protect your feet wherever you play in the KEEN Toyah MJ shoe. This sporty women's mary jane features an offset seam at the toe and undulating contrast stitching along the leather upper, creating distinctive style; an instep strap adjusts for a custom fit. A moisture-wicking leather and fabric lining keeps you dry and comfortable while the metatomical footbed cradles the foot and provides arch support. The KEEN Toyah Maryjane offers rugged construction and plenty of support for comfort on your daily adventures.
  • Adjustable strap with buckle closure
  • Aegis Microbe Shield™
  • Leather and fabric lining
  • Leather upper
  • Leather-topped EVA insole

Style Number: 53005-BLCK

View All KEEN Products

Customer Reviews for Women's KEEN Toyah MJ

92% of respondents would recommend this to a friend.
  • Ratings Distribution

    5 Stars

    4 Stars

    3 Stars

    2 Stars

    1 Star

  • Pros

    Comfortable (100)

    Durable (64)

    Good arch support (63)

    Stylish (57)

    Cushions Impact (51)

  • Cons

    Poor Fit (4)

    Uncomfortable (4)

    Poor Cushioning (3)

    Too Stiff (3)

  • Best Uses

    Casual Wear (97)

    Travel (68)

    Work (60)

    School (42)

    Wet Weather (20)

Displaying Reviews 1-5 of 127 Sort by:
from Port Richey, FL
Exactly what I needed

12 out of 13 people found this review helpful.

These are my 2nd pair of Keens. I like my first pair, but they were too casual for work. I needed something I could wear with dress slacks and something with good arch support because I have a high arch and stand on my feet all day. I will have low back pain if I don't have enough support while standing at work. Not all Keens have high arch support, so I read many reviews and considered many styles. These are exactly what I needed, very comfortable. Nice cushioning in the heel, and throughout. (As is the case with my other Keens.) I ordered this pair in black and they work great with dress slacks. I thought they might be bulky, but they were fine. I wear an 8.5 and they were true to size. I do have a narrow foot but normal width works fine for me and these shoes were no exception - not too wide. The other brand of shoes I wear for arch support are Chacos. I love my Chaco flip flops and saw that Chacos makes a Mary Jane. I decided to order their Loyalist Vibram Gunnison in brown just to have something a little different. I got them on sale on another website that doesn't accept returns or exchanges on sale items. Boy, do I wish I would have just ordered the brown in these Keens from Online Shoes. Online Shoes does carry Chacos, although they didn't have the MJ's, but more importantly they have a great return policy. The Chaco MJ's I received from this other place still have the arch support I've come to love. But the strap is not secure and your heel tends to slip out. These Keens are a better quality MJ so if you are looking for something comfortable, need arch support, stand on your feet all day and need comfort, and need a versatile style for work/office and play, look no further.

Feels true to size
Feels true to width
Bottom line:
YES, I would recommend this to a friend
from Central TX
Comfy and Multi purpose

6 out of 6 people found this review helpful.

I have very problem feet due to ligament damage. This Keen gives me support and toe protection that I love and leave my high arches plenty of room to move. They are well balanced in heel heigth and I can wear them all day without being in tears at the end of it from pain. I also love the way they hold my foot in place which keeps my ankle from twisting. (loose ligament problem again) People notice and compliment them alot. They are my everywhere shoe. They do feel a little big when you first try them on, but once you stand in them and your foot settles in, you find they are just right . I have wide toes and narrow heels and these shoes allow me extreme comfort and protection without bulk.

Feels true to size
Feels true to width
Bottom line:
YES, I would recommend this to a friend
from Iowa
Great support,

5 out of 5 people found this review helpful.

Even more comfortable than the other keen maryjanes, due to the better arch. I have them in 2 colors now!

Bottom line:
YES, I would recommend this to a friend
from NW Indiana
Another cute shoe for Keen

4 out of 4 people found this review helpful.

I am a huge Keen fan, like the other pairs there is no "Breaking In" period required. They feel good from moment one. I also have plantar fascitis and I have no problems wearing these (w/o the presrcibed braces). I recommend to everyone to do your feet a favor... Go Keen. (This style does run long, still debating whether to go a half size smaller).

Bottom line:
YES, I would recommend this to a friend
from Springfield, MO
Way too wide.

3 out of 6 people found this review helpful.

I wear a size 6 and this shoe was too long. They are very stiff and heavy. I had to return them. This shoe has a wide appearance from the top view and they make your feet look big.

Feels half size too big
Feels too wide
Bottom line:
NO, I would not recommend this to a friend
Displaying Reviews 1-5 of 127
About KEEN

Live the HybridLife with KEEN women's shoes, KEEN sandals and KEEN boots—many made with recycled materials. Find KEEN footwear alongside eco-friendly socks and stylish bags.

View All KEEN Products

Welcome back.

An item has been added to your Wish List.

Thank you!

Your account was created and an item has been added to your Wish List.

Always get the best price.

We guarantee you'll always get the lowest price. If you find a better price within 10 days of purchase, call us at 1.800.786.3141 and we'll not only match that price but give you an additional 10% of the difference!

Learn more


Using PayMyWay, you can spread the cost of your order across 3 or 6 payments when using your credit card at checkout.