Print This Page
Customers most agreed on the following attributes:
from North Carolina on 11/15/2008
Excellent shoe! I had been looking for another black pair of shoes that can go with anything from a skirt to a pair of pants and this shoe is definitely it. Also, I have to walk quite a distance to my job site, ok it's good for walking, but remember it's stylish too, so it's not a shoe to overwalk in, so I like everything about the shoe. When I first got it I thought it wasn't going to feel write, but with stockings this shoes is great and my feet never sweats. Attractive and most definitely comfortable indeed!
from Bend, OR on 11/10/2008
Fits well with thin and thick socks. Roomy enough to allow me to spread my toes apart. Buckle is tough, so I leave it set and slide feet in & out. Perforations allow sock color to show through. Not much padding in sole, so may need inserts, otherwise, extremely comfortable from first moment I put them on.
from San Diego, CA on 11/2/2008
I am a chemist and my profession requires that I stand almost all day. The Calistoga from Keen is so comfortable for me and the rubber sole has good cushion that help my feet from the pain of standing and walking for such a long time daily. I like other product from Keen, but this Calistoga one is my favorite since the design is nice, this is my second pair of Calistoga.
from Portland, Oregon on 10/27/2008
Buckles do not unbuckle and the fit is unlike other Keen products. These feel sloppy and not as comfortable as other Keens.
from SE Wisconsin on 10/22/2008
LOVE the Rum Raisin color! (A versatile brick brown.) The perfect casual shoe for fall and winter - very cute with jeans. I've read where the straps can be difficult to manage, but mine are thin enough to buckle and unbuckle with ease. Still, I've only adjusted them once and prefer to use them as slip-ons. The only con I could find is that the size/fit varies greatly from shoe to shoe in this style. If you are between sizes, I recommend ordering both & determining which fits best - and then send the other back.
I got both the 9 and 9.5 and decided to go with the 9.5. It's a bit looser, but with thicker SmartWool socks, they fit nicely. Also my toes don't hit the end, which is important if you plan to wear these for any kind of light trail use or long distance walking around town. Springy, yet firm insoles. These shoes are great if you use any kind of inserts or orthodics.
from ny on 10/21/2008
great quality
from el paso, tx on 10/18/2008
I use these shoes for work. I am a nurse and am on my feet at least 12 hours a day. These shoes are very comfortable and I have recommended them to my co-workers.
from Blair, NE on 10/15/2008
I'm a forth grade teacher who is on her feel all day. I would prefer to wear Keen's every day of the week!!
from Atlanta, GA on 10/14/2008
I wish these shoes were not so long. The width was fine though. I liked them alot but could not walk on canoes!
from Oregon City, Oregon on 10/4/2008
I first discovered these were made for IRON WOMEN when I had to haul grandchildren through knee deep rocky surf in Mexico. I have a green pair that I have run through the washer at least 10 times and painted with glow in the dark and flower puff paint, a red pair, a beige, a brown and a black....I rarely leave home without them.....easy to throw on or off and still look sporty in town,
from Montrose, CO on 9/29/2008
Although I said a little stiff, I haven't worn them but only a couple of times - they don't seem as comfy as my Keen sandals
from Hudson Valley, NY on 9/27/2008
Totally LOVE this shoe. I own several Keen shoes and sandals and am never disappointed with the durability or style. I have 2 very active little boys and teach full time- these shoes, as with my other Keens, work well in my active environments. I have a "C" width foot and these shoes never pinch or feel uncomfortable. The arches feel good, the total shoe shoe feels great from the start to end of my day. Only complaint is that it is difficult to adjust the buckle on the strap becaus the strap is a little wide in the buckle hole.
from Wenatchee, Wa on 9/25/2008
Very cute, great colors, comfy and versatile, just a bit too wide for me, but otherwise fit was good. I would recommend this to a friend.
from Arapahoe County, Colorado on 9/9/2008
This is the most comfortable shoe I have ever bought!! I could wear them right out of the box for a whole day!!! I wish I all my shoes were that way!!!
from East Bay, CA on 8/24/2008
I have two pairs of Keens and love them, so was very excited to try on the new style. The right shoe was great, cute and comfy. The left shoe was impossible to open. I tried 3 PAIRS of this shoe and only one of the six shoes had workable buckles. My husband tried and he couldn't undo the buckles either. The leather strap is too stiff and wide for the buckle. So sorry, really wanted to buy these, the buckle is the only issue. I recommend you try each one, perhaps you'll have better luck.
from Seattle, WA on 8/18/2008
This Keen is a little different cut from the Sydney II's. My feet have bunions and it took a bit longer to break them in. But Keens are great and it's all I wear!
from Waikoloa, HI and Monterey, CA on 8/2/2008
I love this shoe! This is my 5th pair of Keen's and by far one of my favorites. It is versatile-- comfortable on variable terrain and in varying climates. It can be worn with casual attire, or can be a litte dressy too. The buckle is a bit stiff at first, but once adjusted the shoe can be slipped off and on easily without having to use the buckle. This minor disadvantage is completely outweighed by all of the other great features of this shoe! You won't be disappointed!
from Marquette, Michigan on 6/30/2008
I Love all the Keen shoes that I have bought. They are so comfortable and I wont buy anything else. I wear these shoes to work, and I am on my feet all day.
from French Camp, CA on 6/29/2008
I work in a busy emergency room and my feet take a beating! I put these shoes on right out of the box and worked a 12 hour shift in comfort. My co-workers also liked them and since then several of us have bought them. They are very comfortable, very cute, and take a beating.
from Maryland on 6/1/2008
As soon as I put these on, I wanted to wear them everyday - with or without socks. As others reported, the buckle is VERY hard to work. I already just leave it buckled and slide my foot in...probably not the best thing to do, but it works! They look cute with capris or jeans.
from NC Mountains on 5/15/2008
I love Keens! But, many of their styles are too wide for my feet. This is one of those styles. I was really disappointed because I loved the look of this style. However, I did find a replacement style that looks similar and is definitely more narrow. If you have the same problem, check out the Keen Carmel style. Love them!
from NYC on 5/13/2008
I like these shoes but I am disappointed that Keene stopped using their well padded and supportive insoles. I live in NYC and walk and stand a lot. Long walks on pavement are therefore so much less comfortable than in the past--I owned 2 pairs before. But otherwise they are still comfortable, the color is true to the computer image and fun.
from South Carolina on 5/12/2008
Great Shoes!!!! There are no breaking in on Keen's!!! LOVE THEM!!!
from Vancouver, WA on 5/7/2008
I wear this product every day.
from Chicago, IL on 5/7/2008
I recently bought these shoes because I needed good shoes for being on my feet all day at work. I am currently 7 months pregnant, and REALLY needed something that fit well, and was comfortable!! These are fantastic!!
from Columbus, Ga on 4/30/2008
I loved the look of this shoe and it felt very comfortable on my feet, but it rubbed blisters on my heel, even with socks. Had to return...very bummed.
from Sunnyvale CA on 4/27/2008
I usually love all of my keens so when I saw these Calistogas I jumped at the chance to buy a pair that were more girly than the ones that I already had. I was rather disappointed in how heavy and clunky these are. My heels slip even though they are the correct size and the squeaking is embarrassing. I guess my feet get too hot and causes too much humidity in the shoes which causes the squeaking. I've tried wearing socks which decreases the squeak problem but they do not look good with socks.[...]
Keen is THE shoe for me - they're all I own. I used to have a terrible time finding shoes that fit, could be worn in a casual corporate atmosphere and would be comfortable after walking three or four miles. I walk that much every day and I hate having to change my shoes in the middle of the day for work/excercise. I have two pairs of the calistoga, two pairs of canvas ventura, sienna mjs, and a pair of the seattles. They last a long time (3.5 years for the oldest pair), even through a lot of walking. Love them. There are absolutely no downsides to these shoes.
from Ridgway, CO on 4/21/2008
These Keen's are really cute and the color (flamingo) was great! The soles are extremely durable, they could easily be used on any surface, but I couldn't use them, they were just too wide across the toes, there was enough left over room in there to carry around a few pencils!
from Grand Rapids, MI on 4/1/2008
These are the first pair of shoes that I've found that make my feet happy. I have some trouble with my right foot; it hurts by the end of the day. When I wear these, I do not need ibuprofen b/c I have no pain! I needed some padding in the back for the break-in period due to slipping/blistering. But overall, a truly fantastic, adorable shoe. I'm already looking into my 3rd pair of Keens. Love 'em!
from Colorado Springs, CO on 3/19/2008
Fun, comfortable, cute...I get lots of compliments on them. I usually have to get Keens in a larger size, but not these. Plenty of toe room.
from Cape Cod Massachusetts on 2/14/2008
I love my Keens!! This is the 3rd pair of Keens I have purchased. All are different styles and none have yet to disappoint me!! They are the most comfortable shoes I own!! These Calistoga's are even a bit "dressier" and could be worn with skirt!!
from Boston, MA on 2/12/2008
These shoes are adorable! So comfortable! When I first tried them on, I thought they were kind of wide, but now that I've been wearing them, they seem fine. If you have a narrow foot, you may find that there's more room than you like. Otherwise, super comfortable and cute--and I love the little flower cutouts.
from Sedona, AZ on 2/6/2008
I have a mortons neuroma and have settle on Keen's as the only brand of shoes I can wear pain free. I now own 3 different styles of Keens. While the Calistoga is not as comfortable as my hiking/outdoors shoes it saves me from my neuroma pain and is cute enough to wear to work. I'm on my feet a lot at work and my Keens keep me happy.
from Topeka, KS on 1/31/2008
This is my 6th pair of Keen shoes, and I don't think I'll ever buy anything else again. I teach, and I love these shoes for work. They're comfortable, cute, and at the end of the day my feet still feel fine!
from Sparks, NV on 1/30/2008
I LOVE Keens. I have 3 pair now and have retired all of my other shoes in favor of Keens. So far I have only Mary Janes but will buy walking and sandals soon. These shoes fit like your old favorites right out of the box! They look cool with skirts as well as jeans. I am on my feet all day so a comfortable shoe is a must! These particular shoes (Calistoga) are really cute with their tiny flowers. LOVE'em!
from Los Angeles, CA on 1/17/2008
I've been a fan of Keen shoes from the start, but these are my favorites. Comfortable and casual and versatile - can be worn with jeans, pants, or skirts. When I travel, they're the only shoes I take - perfect for endless walking and just about everything else!
My only complaint is that as with most Keen shoes, sizing can be tricky. I have these in three colors - the red ones I bought in my regular size (6) but I had to size up to a 6.5 for the seal brown and black.
from Washington on 1/11/2008
I walked all over Disney World in these shoes, and my feet never felt tired. Super comfortable and stable. These shoes have a place at the front of the closet!
from Elgin, OR on 1/7/2008
I can be on my feet all day and my feet and legs aren't tired at the end of the day. Many people have stopped and asked me about my cute shoes, and ask where I got them. Keen shoes are the only dress shoe I will wear anymore.
from Marion, Norht Carolina on 12/31/2007
Immediately I loved the look and the feel of this shoe.
from Valentine Louisiana on 12/29/2007
I wear these shoes every day. I wear them with jeans, capri's, and slacks. I have gone hiking up and down mountains on vacation with them. I received these shoes, put them on, and did not have to break them in. They were immediately comfortable. I ordered a size larger than my normal size and they fit perfectly. My only hope is that it will become available in additional colors! My only dilemma is deciding which color to wear in the morning.
from Kansas on 12/21/2007
This is the second pair of Keen "Calistoga" that I have bought. Have enjoyed wearing them both...(naturally one is brown, and this pair is black). I'm on my feet a lot during the day, and on weekends shop at the malls. I have found the shoes very comfortable for a long day on your feet!
from Juneau, Alaska on 12/12/2007
I bought this shoe for a warm winter shoe...although I wanted it in RED, my size was unavailable, so I got them in seal brown. It is a nice color and will be a comfortable shoe, although it is a bit stiff right now and will require some "wearing in". I have other Keen shoes and they did not require wearing in...but the material these are made of will. I LOVE the cut-outs...very pretty design! The real buckle is hard for my arthritic fingers, but Keens can be slid into over time.
from Santa Rosa on 12/3/2007
I have a high arch and wide foot and have found it difficult to find comfortable shoes. I now own three pairs of Keens.
[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]
from pa on 12/2/2007
I broke my left leg directly above the joint (all 4 of those little bulbous things) and I have hunted for the right shoe forever and KEEN in general seems to be it. Not too much or too little arch. EXCELLENT SHOE
from JEFFERSON CITY, MO on 12/1/2007
I first saw these shoes and knew they were comfortable and a shoe
that I and my feet would be happy. HAPPY FEET, THATS WHAT MATTERS THE MOST.
from St. Simons Island Ga. on 12/1/2007
I have to wear orthotics and am on my feet all day. This shoe not only allows the orthotics, it is comfortable and trendy too. I find this to be uncommon. I own 3 pairs and would reccomend them to everyone!
from Charleston, SC on 11/29/2007
I am a stay at home Mom and these shoes are great. Very comfy and cute. I get lots of compliments. Great with jeans, Khakis, or cords. For me they are all pro and no con!
from Philadelphia, Pa on 11/26/2007
I walk 6 blocks to and from the train everyday, so I wanted good sturdy, comfortable, cute shoes. These fit the bill! I LOVE them. Totally worth the money. Thanks Keen : )
from Kansas on 11/16/2007
One of the most comfortable pair of shoes I've owned. Light weight, attractive, and stylish.
from Port Washington, WI on 11/15/2007
This shoe feels great right out of the box! I stand and walk around a lot for work and my feet feel great hour after hour. Great shoe for work or play, great detail and overall fun to wear. Use a spray on repellant before wearing because the suede leather will spot. Other than that, I am in the process of replacing all my shoes with Keens!
from Tracys Landing, Maryland on 11/9/2007
First, I received my shoes the NEXT day! I wear my shoes almost every day. I love them and they look as good as I day I received them. Thank You.
from seattle on 9/27/2007
Great Shoe! Has little flower cutout pattern which makes it a bit more girly - but not too cute. Good for work - walking on jobsites where a thick sole is important. I tried this shoe on a a store, so I knew it was a half size too large. [...]
from LaGrande, OR on 9/13/2007
New shoes usually hurt my feet and it's painful to wear them a full day. With these shoes, I wore them all day at work, and my feet weren't even tired at the end of the day. (I am on my feet all day, too!) I love my Keen's!
from Santa Barbara County, California on 8/21/2007
These are my first pair of Keens and I am very happy! Ordered this based on website and reviews and am completely satisfied! Having a 10.5 medium, I often have trouble finding shoes in this size and will try a shoe site unseen! These Keens do not disappoint! Feels perfect with a nice ample toe box, yet with terrific support. Can't wait to get my next pair!
from Boise, ID on 8/5/2007
Very comfortable and can be worn with everything.
from Boise, Idaho on 8/2/2007
I love these shoes! These are the most comfortable shoes I've ever owned. I am a Keen shoes convert. The backs of the heels rubbed a little when I first got them but that only lasted for a week or so and now they're soft and comfy. I get soooo many compliments on them too. I bought the Seattle after I bought these and was a little disappointed in how stiff they are compared to the Callistoga but I'm not ready to give up on Keen yet.