Print This Page
Customers most agreed on the following attributes:
These Mary Janes are very comfortable and I get comments on them often. You would think that they are a little strange looking but, in fact, they are just strange enough to set them apart an grab peoples interest. Very comfortable shoes that can be worn with pants and dresses.
from Lima, OH on 11/10/2008
I really like this shoe, but felt the elastic strap across the in-step of my foot got too tight after the natural swelling of the day. I cut off that strap and love the feel and fit.
Just came back from walking in Italy for 2 weeks with these shoes and they were great. They look good with pants or skirts. With my high arch the elastic strap was tight at first, but loosened with use. However, it still exposed the rough velcro that that strap didn't cover, so my pants' hems were caught and unraveled. I put some other black velcro to cover it to help.
from Indiana on 10/26/2008
Super cute, but the first time I wore them for a short period, I got blisters on the backs of both heels. Also, I have a small narrow foot, and the elastic strap underneath the velcro one seemed to tight and like it would rub and be bothersome. Like other reviewers suggested, I cut it out and it fit perfect. I have since wore them with bandaids on my heels in hopes they just need a bit of breaking in, but other than that, super comfortable. They are much more narrow than other Keens.
from Alabama on 10/23/2008
I have major foot problems and I find these shoes are very comfortable. I added orthodics and cut the elastic out. I walked to and through a large hospital the first day that I wore them and they were wonderful.
from Ogden, Utah on 10/16/2008
I like the looks of this shoe. There is an elastic strap under the regular Mary Jane strap that is really tight over my arch. I think I might just cut it, then the shoe should be really fine.
from CO on 10/10/2008
I love this shoe - it's stylish and comfortable. You can wear it all day with no problems. The strap hides an elastic strap, which for some people might make the shoe too narrow, but it works great for me.
from Washington on 10/7/2008
I teach school so I'm on my feet all day long. The Amsterdam held up to the comfortable and support quality that I've always found in Keen shoes. They were great to wear without socks! I always order a half size larger in Keen shoes.
from Granbury, TX on 10/1/2008
I have to wear an AFO on my right foot and it drags a little too. The other shoes on was wearing lasted about 3 months, then my daughter found these, they lasted about 2 1/2 years. Not to mention how comfortable they are.
from Long Prairie MN on 8/14/2008
I haven't really put these shoes to the test since I got them for a trip I will be going on and doing alot of walking. so far so good.
from St. Louis on 7/18/2008
These are pretty comfortable for everyday use. The toe box seems a little smaller than most Keens, and they can get a little hot after a full day at the zoo in the middle of July (but anything that isn't a flip flop would). They look a little more pulled together than tennis shoes, so nice for traveling, etc.
from Vancouver, WA on 7/15/2008
My extreme heel pain led to my diagnosis of plantar fasciitis in my left foot. I do stretches each morning and wear a foot wrap from the doctor. I wasted money on walking shoes and arch supports--with no relief. I'm on my feet 8+ hours a day at work and I like to walk and ride my bike, but standing all day was painful and walking for fun was out of the question. Just under a year ago, my sister, who also has plantar fasciitis, suggested I try Keens. I did! I've bought three pairs in the past year (black ones for work and fun colors for play). Now I no longer have to wear my foot brace--and I only wear Keens. I no longer have walking shoes, but wear Keens for hiking, bike riding, and at work. I live in rainy Vancouver, WA, and they are waterproof too. My only complaint is that the arches break down, and I can afford to buy them only when they are on sale. I wish my medical plan covered them because Keens really are therapeutic.
from Colorado on 7/15/2008
Great shoe to wear around town. I needed one that I could wear with casual attire, but not be completely dressed down.
from Rochester, NY on 6/25/2008
I am always on the lookout for walking shoes that can stand a fair number of miles, but don't bring down my look like sneakers. These fit the bill. I like them enough that I am now looking at other Keen shoes!
from Suburban Philly, PA on 6/11/2008
I love this shoe! I wear it with shorts, bermudas, and they are so much nicer looking than wearing sneakers. I have a narrow foot, but am able to get a great fit due to the elastic strap under the velcro mary jane strap. The inner liner takes a lot of stress off my feet when walking, but the liner does tend to stick to my bare feet.
from Louisville, KY on 5/29/2008
These are my first Keens, and they are so comfortable, with or without socks. I have had problems in the past locating a shoe that doesn't tear up my ankles or give me immediate hot spots. Also, I'm impressed by the amount of toe room offered with this style of shoe...I have very long toes, and they hardly get a chance to breathe:( Past reviews I have read about this Keen said that the elastic band is bothersome. So far-no problem with it, but I ordered a size bigger than I normally do, an 11 (just in case: and it was a good idea). The Sweat Pea is a deeper green than it appears online...but So Happy!!!!!!!
from Laurel, MD on 5/26/2008
The shoe is VERY comfortable to walk, but it required some patience for adaptation.
The top strap make the area a little bit red, but not a blister.
If you overcome that discomfort the first couple of times you use it, you will have a very comfortable shoe.
from Atlanta, GA on 5/25/2008
A cute shoe, but I have very high arches and a high instep, and it simply did not give me the arch support I need and cut into the top of my foot. The sole felt a bit "thin". I believe, did I not have the arch problem, the shoe would wear well, but with the sole feeling thin, I doubt it would be a good walking shoe. It is stylish enough to wear to work.
from Schaghticoke,NY on 5/20/2008
I wear the shoes wear to work and "out and about". They're comfortable all day. I've finally figures out, any Keen with a buckle I order my regular size -any Keen with a tie I need 1/2 size bigger-interesting...
I LOVE THE LOOK OF THE SHOE. ITS LIGHTWEIGHT HAS STURDY FOOTBED. I WAS VERY EXCITED TO USE THIS SHOE FOR SUMMER TRAVEL, HOWEVER, IM DISSAPOINTED THAT I HAVE TO SEND IT BACK. THE ELASTIC BY THE TOES PINCHES AND WOULD NOT BE GOOD FOR WALKING. I WILL TRY ANOTHER KEEN BECAUSE THE BRAND IN GENERAL IS GREAT.
If you are a loyal Keen customer (I have 9 pr. Keens), this may not be the shoe for you! It is about one inch narrower than all my other Keen styles. Even with the very tight elastic cut, this shoe would be far too narrow for me. I'm returning the shoe--sadly, because it's quite cute.
from Portland, OR on 5/8/2008
OMG people!! These are the best shoes ever! I bought them for an upcoming trip to Europe and can't wait to wear them all over London. They are comfortable beyond belief from the minute you put them on. Try them with the Lorpen walking socks. I am thinking of a second pari.
from Appleton, WI on 5/7/2008
I have the Keen Seattle and Love them! So, I decided to give these a try and they are also GREAT! If you live by the mantra "comfort first" but are determined to be "style-ish" in your pursuit, then these shoes are for you! You won't be disappointed!
from dallas texas on 5/1/2008
these shoes are great. i wear them all the time. friend recommended them and now i know why she wears them for her 12 hour shifts as a nurse.
from nh on 5/1/2008
I wear this shoe with and without socks. Extremely comfortable with a feminine and casual feel.
Since I have heel problems I find I can only wear Keen shoes.
from Bloomfield, Michigan on 4/29/2008
I love this army green color. It's a bit different without being too out there and losing its versitality. Definitely for casual wear, but I can wear them with jeans, shorts, capris, khakis, and I wear them all the time. I did have to break them in for a couple of days, experiencing some rubbing spots, but now these Keens are very comfortable.
from Lincoln, NE on 4/28/2008
Cute shoes just not true to size for me.
from Seattle on 4/17/2008
I love Keens. There is an elastic strap that goes across the top of this shoe, that I may remove, since its a bit tight. But, they're very comfortable. Plus, I like the red, cuz it just makes me happy!
from Minot.ND on 4/16/2008
This shoe is very comfortable even though I need to adjust the point that the elastic hits one foot. I love the look! I've worn lots of Keens and find that some of the shoes run large, some run small. This Mary Jane was true to size on my foot. I'm not sure if it's stain resistant, but it did not mark when water drops got on the shoe.
from Chicago, IL on 4/14/2008
Super cute, I get lots of compliments wearing these, even at work. Love them.
from Seattle, WA on 4/14/2008
Great shoes for jeans, casual pants and capris
from Corona, CA on 4/14/2008
I wanted one of the cute mary jane style sneakers and loved my keen sandals, so I gave these a try. They are super durable, very comfortable, and cute. I chase my kids around in them and they never bother my feet.
from Harlowton, MT on 3/24/2008
This will make a great travel shoe. Light weight and confortable
from Aberdeen, SD on 3/18/2008
I have two pairs of Keen shoes and love them both. They are very comfortable. This shoe I would order in a larger size if you want to wear with a heavier sock. It is a shoe that you can put on and wear all day. It looks great with slack, jeans, or a skirt. It is a color that goes with almost anything.
from SC on 3/4/2008
I now own 3 pair of Keen maryjanes (2 Amsterdam-Black &Coffee Liquer & Barcelona in Moonstone) and I LOVE THEM ALL!!!! I believe the Keen Co. definitely heard the hue & cry of their customers re:the
elastic band that's under the adjustable strap--AND they lengthened it, YAY! THe Black Amsterdams(that I bought) were the original design and that strap was a bit snug and could cause a sore spot on the top of my foot after 8+hrs(until they were stretched out or "broken in"--after a couple of wearings). The Coffee Liquer is a new color and they have given a nice generous length of elastic, voila! problem solved. Love the Coffee Liquer color, nice neutral warm tan--goes w/everything!! Oh and my yorkie accidentally peed on the top of the shoe (an over excited greeting, lol)-I immediately blotted w/paper towel and no stain or odor left!! :)
from Sacramento, CA on 2/28/2008
The delivery was quick. I was able to wear the shoes for long walks right away--no breaking in. They are a shoe that I seem to wear almost every day. I own other shoes by this manufacturer, and they are some of the best shoes on the market. They may not always be the "cutest", but they are by far the most comfortable. Thanks for great prices and service!
from Escondido, CA on 2/16/2008
This is a cute shoe! It's a great shoe for work, has style and also very comfortable for my lunch hour walks.
from Greenville, SC on 2/11/2008
Wonderful shoe, I own 3 pair of Keens, 2 of them in the Amsterdam style. Very comfortable from the 1st moment I put them on. The elastic strap under the velcro strap does pinch and cause soreness on the top of my foot--this seems to dissipate with wearing(breaking in time?) I have read reviews from others on this shoe and they just clipped the elastic and all was fine, it would not be a problem to do this as you still have the adjustable velcro strap and it covers the area. I do have a high arch, and these shoes give me great support in that area (and that may be why I have the problem w/the elastic).
from Fort Wayne, IN on 2/11/2008
I am an Occupational Therapist Assistant, so I am on my feet most of the day. I have 4 pair of Keen shoes, I love them all, they are the most comfortable shoes I have yet to find.
from olympia, wa. on 1/26/2008
I really like these shoes. The one problem I had with them was easy to solve~ they come with a very tight elastic strap that is under the velcro strap. I simply cut the elastic off. I don't see why it's there, anyway, and the shoes were instantly 10 times more comfortable. I have a very high arch, so maybe for me, it was more of an issue. Now I wear them to shop, work (I'm a hairdresser and have given in to comfort over high style these days), and they'd be a great travel shoe. It's winter now, and I've even been wearing them with warm socks, and people comment on how cute they look.
from Boston, MA on 1/25/2008
Another great Keen shoe with solid support. Great for walking.
I bought these before I moved to France and was relieved when they fit right in. They're understated style, versatile, and good for travel.
from South Carolina on 12/13/2007
I have about 10 pairs of Keene shoes and l love them all. I put them on and go... very comfortable immediatly!
from Lincoln, CA on 12/13/2007
Good value for the price.
from Redwood City, CA on 12/11/2007
This shoe is a very comfortable casual shoe. I wear it with slacks and casual skirts. There is a elastic band under the strap across the instep. I'm guessing some folks will find the shoe too narrow as it fits me perfectly and I have a narrow foot. Heel is nicely padded, ball-of-foot has very little padding (you feel the road). I love it.
from Montana on 11/28/2007
I have worn this shoe for hours on end and it has been great for light walking. The shoe is very light, stylish and functional. I have been very pleased with the shoe and would certainly consider another pair in a different color. Several friends have purchased them based on how much I have liked them.
My only con is the strap across the top is a bit tight at the start (the band under the strap is elastic. I almost cut it but let it stretch out instead.
from Indiana on 11/20/2007
Was too small and the color I wanted didn't come in my size (shale, size 6). Very cute shoes, though. I might order a different color. The strap did feel a little tight, but maybe it would stretch or maybe it would be a better fit if I ordered 1/2 size up.
from langhorne, PA on 11/16/2007
Really love these. I am a environmental scientist, but work part-time. So, I leave work around lunch time and have lots of errands & running around to do before I start running my kids around. These keens are like slippers. I forget they are on my feet. The toe was a little snug on my left foot at first (my left foot is a little bigger than my right), but the shoe adapted to my foot after just a couple of wearings.
from Cypress, CA on 11/13/2007
Great shoes, wear well and very comfortable once I removed the elastic band that runs just under the velcro strap. Clean great too! Definitely would recommend!
from Frederick, MD on 11/2/2007
Bought these for walking around Paris. Very comfortable and cute!
from Austin TX on 11/1/2007
I use it for casual comfortable wear and walking shoes.
from Spokane, WA on 10/24/2007
I am very happy with my Keen Amsterdams. I walk to work and needed a shoe that I could walk to work and then wear all day. These fit my needs perfectly. They are very comfortable to walk in and they look nice as a casual work shoe. I wear them on the weekend, too. I am planning on buying another pair in another color. The only problem that I have is that I need more arch support. But I have really high arches and can easily replace the insole. A great shoe! I highly recommend them!
from cleveland, Oh on 10/23/2007
I bought this based on others reviews, as many shoes are too wide for me. Reviews stated that the shoe ran narrow, and it fits perfect. [...]
from Clinton, PA on 10/22/2007
This is my second pair of Keen Amsterdams, and I love the way they feel and look. I can wear them all day long and my feet never hurt. When I wear them in public I have to keep checking my feet to see if I'm wearing my slippers!
from Chicago, IL on 10/19/2007
comfortable with or without socks
from Tampa, FL on 10/19/2007
These are wonderful shoes - I took the advice of some of the other reviewers and cut off the elastic strap under the velcro strap - it made a world of difference, and I would now describe the shoes as feeling great, as well as looking great. These have a lower profile than some of the other Keens I've tried; some of them are too clunky for my taste, but these are edgy and fun.
from Salem, MA on 10/15/2007
I just love these...I walk all over town and love how they look and feel.
from kcks on 10/10/2007
once again, I found a great pair of Keen shoes to wear day after day! You'll love these!